werkregie/doc/prs/2026-10-20-PR#95-own-pr-comments.md

PR#95: Antworten for the User's Own Pull Request That Another Human Commented

Version: minor

WARNING: This document describes only the change applied in this PR. It may already be outdated once the next PR is merged. Historic PR documentation is not maintained along with new PRs; treat it as a snapshot.

Related Links

• hs.hsadmin.ng PR#335, the case: a colleague commented twice after the last commit, and werkregie showed only Wartet auf Review.
• werkregie PR#94, Mergen for the user's own pull request.

Problem

werkregie reads no comments of a pull request. When another human comments on the user's own pull request, the user is to answer or to push a fix; but "Du bist dran" does not show it.

Non-Goals

• No comments on the pull requests of others; an agent watches its own.
• No judgement of the comment, e.g. whether it asks for a change; any comment counts.
• No dismissal of the row; it goes with the user's answer or push.

Specification

Feature: the user's own pull request in which another human has the last word

Scenario#95.01: a comment after the last commit

… so that the user answers the colleague or fixes what the colleague found.

• Given the user's own pull request, whose head commit is older than the comment of hsh-stefanbegerad
• When werkregie reads the pull request
• Then "Du bist dran" shows it under Antworten with "Kommentar von hsh-stefanbegerad"

Verified by

• GiteaSourceTest "a comment of another human after the last commit is the user's to answer"
• GiteaSourceFetchTest "the open pull requests of the user, each with its statuses, reviews and flags"

Scenario#95.02: a review with comments or requested changes

… so that a line comment counts like a comment.

• Given the user's own pull request, and anna submitted a review with line comments or with requested changes after its head commit
• When werkregie reads the pull request
• Then "Du bist dran" shows it under Antworten with "Kommentar von anna"

Verified by

• GiteaSourceTest "a review with comments or requested changes counts as a comment, an approval does not"

Scenario#95.03: the user answered or pushed

… so that the row goes once the user acted.

• Given the pull request of Scenario#95.01
• When the user comments after it, or pushes a commit after it
• Then it shows no Antworten

Verified by

• GiteaSourceTest "an answer or a commit of the user after the comment ends it"

Scenario#95.04: a review bot comments

… so that werkrevisor's result comment on each pull request asks nothing of the user.

• Given the user's own pull request, and only ai-reviewer, one of reviewBots, commented after its head commit
• When werkregie reads the pull request
• Then it shows no Antworten

Verified by

• GiteaSourceTest "a comment of a review bot asks nothing"

Solution

GiteaSource gives the user's own pull request the new flag answer; the page shows it under Antworten. For this flag, werkregie reads the comments of each ready pull request of the user's own: one request more per pull request. Gitea's pull request does not tell the time of its head commit. werkregie reads that time only when another human has the last word: then one request more.

Release Notes

"Du bist dran" shows your own pull request under Antworten when another human commented after your last commit and answer.

Open Questions

None.

Additional Changes

• The user's own pull request on a branch without protection shows no Mergen while Gitea's automerge is scheduled, as the README says; a finding of werkrevisor in werkregie PR#94, verified by GiteaSourceTest "without a branch protection the approval of another human is to merge".
• The English page translates the reasons of werkregie PR#94, "kein Approval nötig" and "hinter main: rebasen, dann mergen".